Nutro vs Blue Buffalo

Nutro vs Blue Buffalo Dog Food Review
The other day I received a panicked call from a friend, Sarah, who just got her first dog.

Her panic was over the abundance of choices of kibble at the pet store, which as a dog parent I totally get.

Her new dog is a medium-sized mix breed. The shelter guessed the dog to be about six years old.

Because she wasn’t sure about the breed or the personality of the dog, I suggested she start with a non-specialty formula, meaning not grain-free or for a specific activity level.

The gal working at the store suggested Nutro and Blue Buffalo.

Unfortunately, these were brands I wasn’t familiar with, so I had to hop online and do some research.

On the surface, both companies looked pretty similar, offering a price-friendly well-balanced food.

I wanted to delve a bit deeper into each company and learn more about their histories and overall product lines.

I was able to find some pretty interesting information about the two companies, though the nicest surprise was the numerous recipe varieties each company offers.

Curious how Blue Buffalo stacks up against other brands? Check out this brand’s comparison with Merrick and Taste of the Wild!

Nutro Company History

Nutro was started by Herben Serois in September of 1931, in Santa Monica, California[1].

Nutro originally sold dog, cat, and fox food to the pet food industry.Nutro Max simple wholesome nutrition dog food brand comparison

In 1942, Mr. Serois passed away at the age of 63.

There is some confusion as to when Mr. Saleen purchased Nutro, but recent evidence shows he purchased Nutro in 1947, not 1926[2].

Nutro was a family operated company until 1975, at which point it was sold for the 3rd time.

There is no documentation regarding who ran the company between the death of Mr. Serois and when Mr. Saleen later purchased it.

Ed Brown, Dave Traitel, and the other unnamed silent partners purchased Nutro in 1975[3].

Between 1975 and 2005, Mr. Brown eventually bought out his partners and took over sole ownership of Nutro until 2005.

A company by the name of Bain & Associates bought the company in 2005 but only kept it for two years, until 2007.

In 2007, Mars Incorporated purchased Nutro[4], making it once again a family owned and operated pet food company.

Nutro has 5 Different Dry Dog Food Lines

Nutro Ultra superfood adult dry dog food real chicken top ingredient protein lamb salmonNutro offers special recipes within each of the five different food lines for different life stages, weight management, and different breed sizes.

The five food lines they offer are:

  1. Ultra
  2. Grain Free
  3. Wholesome Essentials
  4. Limited Ingredient Diet
  5. Max

Nutro 3 Best Selling Dry Dog Foods

  1. Wholesome Essentials Natural Adult Chicken, Brown Rice & Sweet Potato
  2. Max Natural Adult with Farm Raised Chicken
  3. Wholesome Essentials Adult Lamb and Rice

Blue Buffalo Company History

The inspiration behind Blue Buffalo is an Airedale named Blue[5].

The business was started in 2003 by Bill Bishop.

Blue Buffalo was initially a small family owned company; however, in 2018, the Bishop family sold the business to General Mills.

Blue Buffalo VarietiesBlue Buffalo Wilderness high protein grain free Denali Dinner dog food wild halibut venison

Blue Buffalo has 5 different dry dog food lines:

  • Blue Life Protection – There are 23 varieties with specific formulas for adult dogs, puppies, seniors, breed size, and weight management. The Blue Life Protection lines are, “Formulated for the health and well-being,” of dogs.
  • Freedom Grain-Free – Has 12 different options ranging from puppies to seniors and a couple specific to breed sizes.
  • Basics Limited – This line is made up of 13 recipes and are all limited-ingredient formulas for dogs with food sensitivities. There are unique blends for weight management, puppies, adults, and seniors. Also, they have foods based on breed size as well.
  • Blue Wilderness– Like the other diets, they have individual formulas for different life stages and breed sizes. This line was, “Inspired by the diet of wolves, true omnivores whose endurance is legendary,” and is a grain-free high protein option.
  • Blue Natural Veterinary Diet – Exclusive to vet clinics.

Blue Buffalo 3 Best Selling Dry Dog Foods

  1. Life Protection Formula Natural Adult Chicken and Brown Rice
  2. Life Protection Formula Natural Adult Lamb and Brown Rice
  3. Wilderness High Protein Grain Free Natural Adult Salmon

Nutro Recalls

In the last ten years, Nutro has only had one recall that affected their dog food products.Nutro puppy dog food recall any danger safety feed to my dog

The recall occurred in September of 2009 when they discovered plastic on their production line[6].

The following is a list of foods involved:

  • Nutro Ultra Puppy
  • Nutro Natural Choice Chicken Meal Rice
  • Oatmeal Formula Small Bites Puppy

Since the 2009 recall due to plastic on the production line, there hasn’t been any other recalls on their dry dog food.

Blue Buffalo Recalls

Blue Buffalo has had six recalls in the last ten years involving their dog food products:

March 2017 – Blue Wilderness Rocky Mountain Recipe Red Meat Dinner Wet Food for Adult Dogs, due to high levels of beef thyroid hormones[7].

February 2017 – Blue Buffalo Homestyle Recipe Healthy Weight, Chicken Dinner with Garden Vegetables, 12.5 ounce can, due to possible aluminum contamination[8].

February 2017 – The following varieties packaged in the 3.5 oz cup were impacted due to packaging issues with the foil cover[9]:

  • BLUE Divine Delights Filet Mignon Flavor in Gravy
  • BLUE Divine Delights New York Strip Flavor in Gravy
  • BLUE Divine Delights Prime Rib Flavor in Gravy
  • BLUE Divine Delights Rotisserie Chicken Flavor in Gravy
  • BLUE Divine Delights Pate Filet Mignon Flavor
  • BLUE Divine Delights Pate Porterhouse Flavor

  • BLUE Divine Delights Pate Grilled Chicken Flavor
  • BLUE Divine Delights Pate Top Sirloin Flavor
  • BLUE Divine Delights Pate Angus Beef Flavor
  • BLUE Divine Delights Pate Roasted Turkey Flavor
  • BLUE Divine Delights Pate with Bacon, Egg, and Cheese
  • BLUE Divine Delights Pate Sausage, Egg and Cheese Flavor

  • BLUE Divine Delights Pate Steak and Egg Flavor
  • BLUE Wilderness Trail Trays Duck Grill
  • BLUE Wilderness Trail Trays Beef Grill
  • BLUE Wilderness Trail Trays Chicken Grill
  • BLUE Wilderness Trail Trays Turkey Grill

Blue Wilderness healthy holistic dog food treat voluntary recalls potential salmonella contamination

Does “New and Improved!” mean “Salmonella free”?

May 2016 – 30lb Blue Buffalo Life Protection Formula Fish & Sweet Potato Recipe, due to high moisture content[10].

November 2015 – Cub Size Wilderness Wild Chews Bones, due to possible salmonella contamination[11].

October 2010 – The following foods were impacted due to possible excess Vitamin D[12]:

  • 4.5#, 11#, 24# Blue Wilderness Chicken Flavor dry dog food
  • 11#, 24# Blue Basics Limited Ingredient Formula Salmon and Potato Recipe dry dog food
  • 30# Blue Life Protection Formula Natural Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Large Breed Adult dog food

Most of these were voluntary recalls made due to the possibility of contamination, with no or minimal negative effects.

What’s Important When Choosing a Dog Food?

Obviously, we know that ingredients are essential in deciding which food would be the best match for our dog, but numerous other factors impact our buying decision.

There are two groups of elements that help us decide on the best dog food choice for our dogs.

The first group is the primary factors that directly relate to our dog’s specific needs, and the other group is the secondary aspects that aren’t related to our dogs.

Primary Factors

  • Health – Heart or kidney disease, GI issues such as chronic pancreatitis or irritable bowel disease, allergies, and so on can require dietary changes
  • Size
  • Age
  • Weight (gain or loss)
  • Energy Level

Secondary Factors

  • The dog food company’s reputation
  • Availability
  • Ingredients
  • Where the food is manufactured
  • Where the ingredients are sourced
  • Price 

Comparison of Nutro vs. Blue Buffalo

Ingredients

  Winner: Blue Buffalo   

Blue Buffalo Life Protection Formula with LifeSource Bits large breed adultThis was almost a tie since the two companies have similar product line variations; however, Blue Buffalo has enriched their foods with probiotics and also has a higher fiber, omega-6, and omega-3 fatty acids content.

Another enhancement Blue Buffalo made to their products was to add BLUE LifeSource Bits, which are a precise blend of antioxidants, vitamins and minerals.

Nutro does have impressive, extensive food lines. It is worth noting that their dry dog foods are all made up of non-GMO ingredients.

Price/Value

  Winner: Nutro   

The average price per pound for Nutro is about a dollar fifty and the average price per pound for Blue Buffalo over two dollars.   

The X Factor

  Winner: Blue Buffalo   

Blue Buffalo’s exclusive LifeSource Bits are unique, and the added bump in antioxidants, vitamins, and minerals is a definite bonus in any dog food.

Availability

  Winner: Blue Buffalo   

Blue basics limited ingredient quality comparison which is better turkey potato recipeBlue Buffalo is available in almost all large pet stores, some boutique stores (but only select lines), some large hardware stores, and grocery store chains.

Nutro is available in most of the large chain stores like Pet Smart, Target, and Walmart, but not as many places as Blue Buffalo.

You can find Nutro at both Amazon and Chewy.

You can get Blue Buffalo from both Amazon and Chewy as well.

Taste

  Winner: Blue Buffalo   

Dogs seem to prefer Blue Buffalo over Nutro.

The ingredient lists are similar, so there’s no apparent reason that stands out as to why one is preferred over the other except for the vagaries of taste.

Overall

  Winner: Blue Buffalo   

Blue Buffalo and Nutro are very similar products, but Blue Buffalo is available at more retailers, has the LifeSource Bits, and more importantly, the dogs’ votes!

Conclusion

If you are deciding between the two brands and are unable to choose between the two, maybe consider the fat and protein content.

The crude analyses between the foods vary and depending on your dog’s needs, and those might be worth factoring into your decision.

Also, if you are purchasing the food from a pet food retailer, many will let you return the open bag of food if your dog doesn’t eat it.

Resources

  1. http://billiondollarkibble.com/lineage/herben-serois/
  2. https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/cooper-consulting-group-inc-publishes-new-book-billion-dollar-kibble—nutros-story-of-pioneering-among-giants-300513717.html
  3. http://billiondollarkibble.com/lineage/john-saleen/
  4. https://www.bloomberg.com/research/stocks/private/snapshot.asp?privcapId=4360956
  5. https://bluebuffalo.com/why-choose-blue/blue-story/
  6. http://www.dogfoodadvisor.com/dog-food-recall/nutro-dog-food-recall-2009-sep/
  7. https://www.fda.gov/safety/recalls-market-withdrawals-safety-alerts/blue-buffalo-voluntarily-recalls-one-lot-blue-wildernessr-rocky-mountain-recipe-tm-red-meat-dinner
  8. https://bluebuffalo.com/about-us/whats-new-at-blue/bb-homestyle-recipe-letter/
  9. https://www.ohiovma.org/news/?p=3399
  10. https://www.petsmartcorporate.com/blank-1/2016/05/27/USPR-Voluntary-Product-Recall-of-30lb-Blue-Buffalo-Life-Protection-Formula-Fish-Sweet-Potato-Recipe-for-Dogs-%E2%80%93-May-27-2016
  11. http://wayback.archive-it.org/7993/20170112071547/http:/www.fda.gov/Safety/Recalls/ArchiveRecalls/2015/ucm474573.htm
  12. http://wayback.archive-it.org/7993/20170112111823/http:/www.fda.gov/Safety/Recalls/ArchiveRecalls/2010/ucm228986.htm
About the author

Jessica Mabie

Jessica and her husband share their lives with four amazing high energy Brittanys and one very awesome cat. You’ll rarely see her without her 4 pack, they go everywhere with her, including most vacations. So, if you see her out and about with her family don’t hesitate to say “Hi!”, (You’ll know it’s her since few are so daring as to have 4 Britts).