NomNomNow Review

NomNomnow Dog Food Delivery Service Review

NomNomNow

9.2

Ease-of-Use

9.7/10

Price

8.1/10

Ingredients

9.4/10

Tastiness

9.6/10

Pros

  • 4 Recipe Options
  • Multi-Pet Discount
  • Offers partial portions if you're using the food as a food topper versus a whole meal
  • Partnered with local shelters and rescues

Cons

  • Cost. It's more expensive than kibble, but I think it is reasonably priced. Unfortunately, it's a price point that is prohibitive to many.
  • There's an additional charge on weekly orders containing multiple recipes.

 

Of my four dogs I have two very picky eaters. But my oldest, Daisy, is the pickiest of them all.

We’ve tried everything possible to get Daisy to eat. Finally, it got to the point that I started cooking all of her meals.

To ensure I was providing well-balanced nutritious meals I made an appointment with a nutritionist, Dr. Churchill, DVM, at the University of Minnesota.

We left the appointment hopeful, with a specially formulated vitamin/nutrient supplement in hand. We had food recipes specially created just for Daisy and thought this would be the end of our food battle.

It wasn’t.

She wouldn’t eat the homemade food with the supplement, so we were back to our game of “What will Daisy eat today?”

In an interesting turn of fate, around this time I was contacted by someone from NomNomNow. They offered to send out a sample for my picky eater to test out. It sounded good, and I’m always up to trying a new food for Daisy.

Looking through the ingredient list I couldn’t help to notice it contained their “NomNomNutrient Mix“. I absolutely understand the necessity of it, but I was no longer hopeful that Daisy would eat this food.

Did NomNomNow pass Daisy’s standards?

Central Park Paws readers get 30% off their first NomNomNow order!

CLAIM DISCOUNT

What the Heck is NomNomNow (besides a cute name)?

The FoodOpening the Porkalicious Potluck fresh handmade dog food from NomNomNow

Simply put, NomNomNow is dog food made from fresh, wholesome ingredients. All food is made to order.

There are 4 varieties to choose from:

  • Heartland Beef Mash
  • Tasty Turkey Fare
  • Chicken Chow-Wow
  • Porkalicious Potluck

The Service

NomNomNow is food delivered to your door. It’s packed with dry ice and well insulated.

There’s also a Pet Profile Account, which allows you to make changes to your orders, shipping, and general account information.

You also get some nifty bonuses:

  • They gift you a complimentary variety pack with your first order.
  • They provide 7 emergency meals (free of charge) with your second delivery

Emergency meals are kept in the freezer, “… life happens, and should a delivery ever get lost or stolen, these will ensure that your dog never goes without their NomNomNow”.

My NomNomNow Experience…

Nomnomnow freeze dried dog food box dry ice keeps cold and fresh

I ordered my variety pack on a Friday which, for my area, is after the deadline, and it arrived two weeks later.

Had I ordered before the deadline, for example on Wednesday, I would’ve received the food in a week.

When the box arrived, there was no guesswork to what was inside.

I was a bit curious as to what method NomNomNow used to keep the food cold.

Nomnomnow unboxing what's in the box dog food service review contents

To ensure the food was kept at the correct temperature, the box contained insulation and a packet of dry ice.

The food was frozen when I received it.

Because I wasn’t sure about exposing it to heat, not knowing if it would change the nutritional content, I let it thaw overnight in my fridge.

I chose to start with the Porkalicious Potluck, the reason being that Sophie has food allergies and the pork variety didn’t contain anything she’s allergic to.

Sophie eating her Nomnomnow best tasting dog food for sale

Sophie nomming the NomNomNow

Here’s what the dogs thought:

You can’t see it, but Sophie was scoop shoveling the food into her mouth…

And Daisy (she just got a bath, thus the spiky hair) liked it so much she went over to help Calvin finish his…

Ginger had crazy eyes when she was eating it, so I didn’t feel like sharing that picture, but it was clear the dogs loved the food.

We’ve since opened the other packets and, though they ate them, they were not all received with the same enthusiasm.

Both dogs eating their food do dogs like NomNomNow

Daisy “helping” Calvin finish off his food

Here’s how the dogs would rank them:

  1. Porkalicious Potluck
  2. Tasty Turkey Fare & Chicken Chow-Wow – Definitely well liked, but not as strongly as the Porkalicious Potluck.
  3. Heartland Beef Mash –  Not the favorite. They just picked at it.

Based on my dogs’ reactions, NomNomNow is a winner!

It’s terrific my dogs enjoyed the food, but I still had some questions that needed answers before I placed our first order.

Let’s Talk Ingredients

I love that the food is all human-grade and cooked to order.

Though nutritional supplements still needed to be added, I’m happy to see a lot of the nutrition is coming directly from a fresh source.

After reading through each of the recipes, I learned only one has brown rice and the others use potatoes as the carbohydrate.

I know a lot of people have steered toward grain-free foods, but recent studies are finding that grain-free diets may cause Dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM).

Yes, some dogs are more prone to DCM than others, so grain-free food may not be a concern.

I like that the recipe page not only includes the recipes but also indicates the nutritional benefits for each ingredient.

Who Created These Recipes?

Nomnomnow Porkalicious Potluck high quality ingredients whole foods nutrients

It was nice to read about who actually came up with the recipes. With most dog foods you don’t have the comfort of knowing who the nutritionist is and their mission.

The recipes at NomNomNow were formulated by Dr. Justin Shmalberg “…one of the world’s foremost experts in veterinary nutrition.”

I looked into Dr. Shmalberg a bit more to see if this claim was accurate or not and it absolutely is.

He’s published numerous scientific papers in veterinary medicine and frequently lectures on nutritional topics to veterinarians. His credentials can also be found at the University of Florida’s Vet Medicine‘s website.

How Does NomNomNow Compare to a Raw Diet?

For me, it doesn’t compare.

Many veterinarians have warned me away from raw diets.

Raw diets carry the risk of Salmonella, Clostridium, Listeria and other bacteria found in raw meat. In addition to infection, there’s also the risk of broken teeth and internal punctures from the bones.

Also, many raw diets aren’t nutritionally balanced, which can have adverse effects on a dog’s health over time.

Alternatives

I looked into three similar dog food companies, and this is what I found:

Fresh Pet

Pros

  • Can be found at local grocery stores
  • Is the most economical

Cons

  • Not made to order
  • Less whole food ingredients than the others
  • Appears to be mechanically processed

Learn More

Farmers Dog

Pros

  • Bulk discount
  • Allows for multi-recipe orders without additional Charge.

Cons

  • The varieties were not listed on the website. I had to call to get a list of recipes and ingredients.
  • Only 3 formulas: Beef, Pork, and Turkey.
  • Their website doesn’t provide much information unless you sign up.
  • Cost. It’s more expensive than kibble.

Learn More

My Ollie

Pros

  • 4 Recipes
  • Donates 1% of their revenue to a rescue organization

Cons

  • No Multi-Pet Discount
  • Cost. It’s a lot like human food; the fresher and healthier the food, the more it may cost.

Learn More

Overall, there were some universal benefits amongst NomNomNow, My Ollie, and The Farmers Dog.

  • Free shipping
  • Made Fresh to Order
  • Excellent Customer Service (I called all three)
  • No ingredient Substitutions – so, if your dog has allergies, you can’t adjust recipes to accommodate their food restrictions.

Why NomNomNow is the Favorite

  • Their Emergency Meal feature.
  • The variety pack so your pet can try all four flavors.
  • They introduced the nutritionist behind the recipes.
  • Their website is easy to navigate.
  • NomNomNow is great for a variety of dog breeds, from Pomeranians to German Shepherds.

Central Park Paws readers get 30% off their first NomNomNow order!

CLAIM DISCOUNT

Conclusion

I think freshly made dog food is a great idea, as long as you are feeding a balanced diet.

Because a dog’s nutrition needs are different than ours, I would only recommend a fresh dog food if it’s been approved by a veterinarian specializing in nutrition.

If you’ve ever tried making your dogs food you know how time consuming it is, which makes companies like NomNomNow so valuable.

Fresh dog food isn’t for everyone, and I’m not even saying it’s better than kibble.

I do think that it’s a great alternative when you have a dog that’s really finicky or one that needs a more specialized diet.

About the author

Jessica Mabie

Jessica and her husband share their lives with four amazing high energy Brittanys and one very awesome cat. You’ll rarely see her without her 4 pack, they go everywhere with her, including most vacations. So, if you see her out and about with her family don’t hesitate to say “Hi!”, (You’ll know it’s her since few are so daring as to have 4 Britts).