Hill’s Prescription Diet ID Dog Food Alternatives

Hill’s Prescription Diet I/D Dog Food Alternatives

QUICK PICKS

Best Overall Choice

American Journey Limited Salmon & Sweet Potato

Natural Balance Limited Ingredient Diet grain free Hills alternative

Budget Pick

Natural Balance L.I.D. Grain-Free Duck & Potato

Orijen-Original-Dry-Dog-Food

Upgrade Pick

ORIJEN Original

This post may contain affiliate links. It doesn’t cost you anything extra and it keeps our lights on, our families fed, and our dogs spoiled. For all the juicy fine print, see our affiliate disclosure

Best Alternatives for Hill’s I/D Dog Food: Winners

Many vets prescribe Hill’s Prescription Diet I/D for dogs suffering from an upset digestive system.

It’s a popular dog food, but it might not be the most suitable one because it contains more than recommended vitamin D levels, according to the Food and Drug Administration1.

In addition, it also doesn’t offer the best taste, so many dog owners look for Hill’s Prescription Diet I/D alternatives.

If you’re looking for the same, the American Journey Limited Salmon & Sweet Potato Grain-Free Dry Dog Food is your best bet.

Just like Hill’s I/D diet, it regulates an upset digestive system of a dog, but at the same time, it also helps adult dogs of all breeds to maintain lean muscle.

I have selected some of the best Hill’s I/D diet alternatives that you can use for your lovely pet.

Read the following reviews carefully to choose the best food for your dog based on its age, size, breed, and other needs.

Related: The Best Alternatives to Hill’s Prescription Diet C/D

Overall best alternative to Hill's Prescription Diet I/D American Journey Limited Ingredient Salmon Sweet Potato Recipe

Overall Best – American Journey Limited Salmon & Sweet Potato Grain-Free Dry Dog Food

American Journey Limited Salmon & Sweet Potato grain-free dry food is our top pick because it offers many benefits other than regulating the upset digestive system.

Not only does it cost less than Hill’s I/D diet but it’s also completely safe for adult dogs of all breeds.

Is Your Dog Driving You Nuts During the Day?

Indoor Activities for Dogs

Get Our List of 11 Awesome Indoor Activities to Keep Your Dog Busy and Out of Trouble!

It’s a limited ingredient dog food that only contains protein from a single animal, and it also doesn’t offer any grains.

This also means you can use it for dogs suffering from itchy skin and sensitive stomachs.

The main ingredient is boneless salmon, and the formulation is completely balanced, which can also improve your pup’s coat.

Check Price

Important
  • Top 5 ingredients: Salmon meal, deboned salmon, chickpeas, peas, and sweet potatoes
  • Guaranteed Analysis: Crude protein 25 percent min, crude fat 12 percent min, crude fiber 6 percent max, moisture 10 percent max
  • Special Diet: Limited ingredients, free of grain, corn, soy, wheat, and chicken diet with high-protein and sensitive digestion
  • Lifestage: Adult
  • Best for: Small, medium, and large breeds
Natural Balance Limited Ingredient Diet grain free Hills alternative

Budget Pick – Natural Balance L.I.D. Grain-Free Duck & Potato Dry Dog Food

Unlike Hill’s I/D dog diet, the Natural Balance L.I.D. Grain-Free Duck & Potato dog food comes in a dry form.

The number one ingredient in this blend is a farm-raised duck, and you can use it for adult dogs of all breeds.

It offers the taste, quality, and nutritional value that your doggie dude deserves.

You can use it to serve the taste buds of pups experiencing an upset digestive system as it doesn’t contain any added wheat, corn, legumes, lentils, pea protein, and peas.

Check Price

Important
  • Top 5 ingredients: Duck, duck meal, cassava flour, sweet potatoes, and brewers dried yeast
  • Guaranteed Analysis: Crude protein 24 percent min, crude fat 10 percent min, crude fiber 4 percent max, moisture 10 percent max
  • Special Diet: Free of grain, corn, soy, wheat, pea, and chicken, limited ingredient diet with sensitive digestion
  • Lifestage: Adult
  • Best for: Small, medium, and large breeds
ORIJEN Original chicken turkey fish mostly animal dry dog food

Upgrade Pick – ORIJEN Original Grain-Free Dry Dog Food

The ORIJEN Original Grain-Free Dry Dog Food is based on whole animal ingredients.

Unlike Hill’s Prescription Diet I/D, ORIJEN Original adds the first five ingredients (mentioned below) in this diet in a fresh or raw form to ensure freshness.

It’s suitable for adult dogs of all breeds and helps support your pet’s digestive system.

In addition, it offers a fantastic flavor-rich taste that your pup will love.

You can use this food even if your dog has a sensitive or upset stomach.

Check Price

Important
  • Top 5 ingredients: Turkey, chicken, chicken liver, flounder, and whole mackerel
  • Guaranteed Analysis: Crude protein 38 percent min, crude fat 18 percent min, crude fiber 4 percent max, moisture 12 percent max
  • Special Diet: Free of grain, gluten, corn, soy, and wheat, natural diet with high protein content
  • Lifestage: Adult
  • Best for: Small, medium, and large breeds
NomNomNow Chicken Cuisine great homemade diet for limited ingredient dogs

Best Subscription Alternative to Hill’s I/D – NomNomNow Chicken Cuisine

What makes NomNomNow Chicken Cuisine better than Hill’s Prescription Diet I/D dog food is that it’s available in different blends for different breeds, sizes, and ages.

It’s made with high-quality ingredients and ensures your pet’s health by preventing chronic diseases.

The company claims that it uses technologically advanced techniques and a one-of-a-kind machine to manufacture perfectly balanced and complete dog foods.

Other than regulating the vital functions of a dog’s body, the NomNomNow foods also promote muscle mass and strength (see our NomNomNow review).

Check Price

Important
  • Top 5 ingredients: Diced chicken, spinach, squash, sweet potatoes, and water for processing
  • Guaranteed Analysis: Crude protein 8.5 percent min, crude fat 6 percent min, crude fiber 1 percent max, moisture 77 percent max
  • Special Diet: Prevent chronic diseases
  • Lifestage: All AAFCO dog food profiles are available2
  • Best for: Large, medium, and small breeds
Purina Pro Plan Veterinary Diet EN Gastroenteric alternative to Hill's I/D

Best Hill’s I/D Alternative with Prebiotics – Purina Pro Plan Veterinary EN Gastroenteric Dry Dog Food

Purina Pro Plan is known for its great taste and high-quality ingredients, and the Veterinary EN Gastroenteric Dry Dog Food is no exception.

It offers a better nutritional value than Hill’s Prescription Diet I/D and suits adult dogs of all breeds the best.

The pea-free formulation that includes healthy antioxidants and prebiotic fiber with grains is ideal for dogs with sensitive digestion.

It’s designed to promote total digestibility with its optimal nutrient absorption functionality.

Check Price

Important
  • Top 5 ingredients: Animal fat preserved with mixed-tocopherols, brewers rice, whole grain corn, corn gluten meal, and chicken meal
  • Guaranteed Analysis: Crude protein 23 percent min, crude fat 10.5 percent min, crude fiber 2 percent max, moisture 12 percent max
  • Special Diet: Pea-free sensitive digestion veterinary diet with grains
  • Lifestage: Adult
  • Best for: Toy, extra small, small, medium, large, and giant breeds

How to Transition Your Dog to a New Food

If you don’t already know, dogs can rely on the very same diet for a long period.

In fact, changing their diet frequently is not advisable because it can lead to some health issues in dogs, like an upset digestive tract.

That’s why you should add new food to your pup’s diet plan gradually. Ideally, it should take about seven weeks, but it can be longer depending upon your dog.

A good strategy is to add the new food in a small quantity to your dog’s current diet plan.

Then increase the amount of new food gradually each day to safely switch to a new diet plan.

To learn in detail about switching dog foods the right way, click here.

Important Note: It’s not advisable to change your dog’s current diet without a vet’s advice.

Best Alternative to Hill’s I/D

I found that American Journey Limited Salmon & Sweet Potato Grain-Free Dry Dog Food is the best alternative to Hill’s Prescription Diet I/D diet.

It supports your dog’s digestive system, but it also makes for an excellent option for pups suffering from a sensitive stomach or itchy skin.

American Journey Limited Ingredient great dog food for digestion

You can buy the American Journey Limited Dog Food today to add it to your dog’s diet plan after consulting with your vet.

Resources

  1. https://www.fda.gov/animal-veterinary/outbreaks-and-advisories/fda-alerts-pet-owners-and-veterinarians-about-potentially-toxic-levels-vitamin-d-33-varieties-hills
  2. https://www.dogfoodadvisor.com/frequently-asked-questions/aafco-nutrient-profiles/

Still Have Questions?
Ask a Vet!

Eliminate Bad Dog Breath Without Brushing

Fresh Breathies